|   
                   Collective 
                    Intelligence, a civilisation 
                    By 
                    Pierre Lévy (UQTR) 
                  
                  (first 
                    published in "Crossings" e journal of art and technology, 
                    Dublin University, translation from the french by Colin Bell) 
                  
                  Towards 
                    a method of positive interpretation 
                  
                  I 
                    foretell the coming of one planet-wide civilisation based 
                    on the practice of collective intelligence in Cyberspace. 
                    However, before coming to the crux of the matter, I would 
                    first like to justify my methodology, which is not that of 
                    scientific prediction but rather of poetic imagination. To 
                    contrast prediction and imagination in this manner is not 
                    to imply that imagination equates with falsehood and illusion. 
                    On the contrary, I believe that imagination, and especially 
                    collective imagination, produces reality. In choosing 
                    imagination over prediction, I mean to underline the fact 
                    that the future has not yet been written and that we are probably 
                    much more free than we think. We are responsible for the world 
                    which we create together through our thoughts, words and deeds. 
                    That is why I am convinced that it is much more constructive 
                    to use our own powers of perception and freedom of choice 
                    in a creative manner rather than denounce, judge and condemn 
                    the world as it is, that is to say, at the end of the day, 
                    others. Does this mean that we should abandon our critical 
                    faculties, our ability to differentiate? Of course not. Rather, 
                    every positive thought, word and deed subtly indicates the 
                    path which it has chosen not to take. The fact of indicating 
                    and then taking a certain path implies a critique 
                    of those not taken. When we exercise our freedom, and our 
                    poetic freedom amongst other things, we necessarily evaluate 
                    the alternatives before making a choice. However, in doing 
                    this, creative imagination summons a world yet to come rather 
                    than reinforcing negative stereotypes, prolonging conflicts 
                    or entrenching differences. 
                  It 
                    does not do this from nothing, nor does it simply follow its 
                    own whims. Proceeding relentlessly by direct observation and 
                    attempting to overcome all prejudices, I endeavour to identify, 
                    from amongst the thousands of embryonic forms which the current 
                    situation has created, those which, given the opportunity 
                    to develop fully, will be most propitious to increasing our 
                    freedom. As I conceive it, creative imagination cannot therefore 
                    be dissociated from a process of reading and interpreting 
                     a sort of profound vision  for which reality 
                    and meaning are not a given, but are instead potential, only 
                    to be revealed by an act of free understanding. From amongst 
                    the infinite number of virtual paths possible, creative interpretation 
                    selects one. However, this freedom is not arbitrary  
                    it must refrain from relying on pre-existing concepts and 
                    vested interests in its projection of meaning. It attempts 
                    to give a certain life back to the text, the image or the 
                    situation in its entirety, a life whose outpouring will overturn 
                    prejudices, predictions and beliefs. The material objectivity 
                    of the world, the reality which everybody can clearly 
                    see (and which changes with each culture, period, theory, 
                    subjective point of view) is only ever a sclerosis of creative 
                    intelligence, an inability to capture the evolutionary and 
                    organic nature of the world. Thus I conceive of situations 
                    as landscapes of possibility which my perceptions, interpretations 
                    and deeds will develop in one direction or another. At any 
                    given moment, the world is made up of a mosaic of signs, each 
                    of which opens a door onto another mosaic, and so on infinitely. 
                    Which handle should we turn? Which link should we click on? 
                    In the Romance languages, semence and semantics 
                    share the same root, both connote the virtual, the potential 
                    of the future, be it in the domain of organic life or in that 
                    of meaning. In the immense landscape made up from grains of 
                    meaning, which seeds should we water? 
                  The 
                    most interesting question is not therefore is this interpretation 
                    true?, but rather what type of path does this 
                    interpretation open up? To which reality does it give 
                    rise? Will it harden our everyday experience, render it more 
                    solid, material and painful? Or will it give rise to an increase 
                    in freedom, a further refinement in the play of signs, an 
                    affirmation of life in the world and of the pleasure of existing? 
                  If 
                    I choose to interpret the more positive signs, 
                    those which carry freedom within, it is not because I wish 
                    to claim that all is well, nor that society is 
                    not unjust, nor that all suffering has vanished. It is rather 
                    to conjure up as vividly as possible, in my mind as well as 
                    in that of my reader, the paths which lead towards emancipation. 
                    For there can be no doubt regarding the best route to take: 
                    that of freedom. 
                  
                  Our 
                    responsibility 
                  
                  The 
                    Internet is a truly Surrealist mode of communication from 
                    which nothing is excluded, neither good nor evil, 
                    nor their many forms, nor the debate which would vainly attempt 
                    to separate them. The Internet represents the unmediated presence 
                    of humanity to itself since every possible culture, discipline 
                    and passion is therein woven together. The fact that everything 
                    is possible on the Internet reveals mankinds true essence, 
                    the aspiration towards freedom.  
                  Just 
                    like truth and falsehood, good and evil also belong to the 
                    world of language and grow in complexity with it. What is 
                    this chaos which dominates Cyberspace just as it does the 
                    contemporary world? Where can order be found? This is what 
                    we would like to know. We look high and low, join different 
                    clans, argue, lose the run of ourselves, fight
 We denounce 
                    evil on all sides, always ready to point the finger 
                    at others. We eagerly swarm over all sorts of goods. 
                    And, in doing this, we complicate everything, we accelerate 
                    the process of evolution, just like the wind and certain animals 
                    disperse plant seeds far and wide, contributing to the evolution 
                    of the vegetable ecology. The Internet will reveal the true 
                    hierarchy of good, because what is at stake is the essence 
                    of language: freedom. This hierarchy is complex: hyper-textual, 
                    interwoven, alive, mobile, teeming and spinning like a biosphere. 
                     
                  Many 
                    of us already take part in the on-line exchange of ideas, 
                    information and services. We engage in dialogue in virtual 
                    communities housed by mobile networks which are continually 
                    being reconfigured. Soon we will all have our own web site. 
                    In a few years, we will avail of avatars or digital angels 
                     capable of conversing on their own  to send our 
                    memories, projects and dreams out into Cyberspace. Every individual, 
                    group, life-form and object will become its own self-medium, 
                    emitting data and interpreting itself in a mode of communication 
                    whose transparency and richness will stimulate through opposition. 
                  Omnivision 
                    will replace television: no matter where we may find ourselves, 
                    we will be able to use Cyberspace to direct our gaze to any 
                    part of the world which we choose. And the intensity of that 
                    gaze, just like the insistency of our questions, will give 
                    rise to an infinite amount of new details. Driven by our desire 
                    to know, we will learn everything it is possible to learn, 
                    from the constellations to social situations, from scientific 
                    experiments to interactive fictions. To whoever can formulate 
                    a question, all will become visible from every point in space 
                    or time, every direction, every level. However, this all 
                    or this every do not predate our questions and 
                    techniques. Rather, they result from our questions, they are 
                    its never finished  unfinishable  task. Reality 
                     including the reality of biological life  will 
                    become more and more alive, intelligent and interconnected; 
                    it will resemble interactive simulations more and more and 
                    will be increasingly designed in the digital matrixes which 
                    make up virtual worlds. 
                  We 
                    will take part in on-line role-playing games whose aim will 
                    be to invent virtual worlds which resemble the real world 
                    as closely as possible (and vice versa). The winners will 
                    be those who conceive of the most ingenious new forms of cooperation. 
                    We will learn the ever-changing rules of creative collaboration 
                    and collective intelligence in a universe fed by heterogeneous 
                    sources of information. It will be impossible to tell whether 
                    the virtual communities which provide this apprenticeship 
                    are on-line universities, communications companies, games 
                    worlds or deterritorialised democratic agorae.  
                  No 
                    reference, authority, dogma or certitude will remain unchallenged 
                    by the future which awaits us. We are now discovering that 
                    reality is a collective creation. We are all in the process 
                    of thinking within the same network. This has always been 
                    the case, but Cyberspace renders it so evident that it can 
                    no longer be ignored. Now is the time of responsibility. 
                  Such 
                    power, freedom and responsibility can only oblige us to be 
                    audacious in creating new paths to the future. In one sense, 
                    nothing will ever change. As always, we will be born, suffer, 
                    love, weave beautiful and meaningful patterns together, and 
                    then we will grow old and die. However, in another sense, 
                    we are now in the position to invent a new human reality, 
                    just as at the end of the Neolithic period mankind evolved 
                    by inventing agriculture, the town, the state and writing. 
                    The present mutation is, however, much more rapid. In place 
                    of agriculture, biotechnologies now offer us the risky possibility 
                    of guiding the biospheres evolution in real time. The 
                    convergence of life  which is increasingly genetically 
                    modified and artificial  and technology  which 
                    is increasingly alive and intelligent  will leave us 
                    free to pursue more creative enterprises. Instead of towns, 
                    we are now constructing one planet-wide metropolis, connected 
                    by air, road and rail links. We are in the process of building 
                    one transcontinental, omnipresent capital which will comprehend 
                    high-finance, science, the media and entertainment industries: 
                    therein, everything circulates, people, signs, mobile communications 
                    machines, interconnected means of transport. Linked by bolts 
                    of information which flash between them like lightning, the 
                    skyscrapers of Hong Kong, New York and Sao Paulo sing the 
                    praises of the Almighty Dollar (higher praise than that given 
                    to their respective gods by Egyptian pyramids or European 
                    cathedrals). The unending conversation of Cyberspace carries 
                    on the process started by the semi-divine priest-kings of 
                    Antiquity when they first engraved laws on stone tablets. 
                    We discuss the changing meaning of laws in an intellectual 
                    climate where documents and facts are never further away than 
                    the next hypertext link. The pros and cons of every issue 
                    will be redistributed in numerous virtual forums, like so 
                    many synapses in one giant brain whose neurons flicker on 
                    and off, and we will vote for new laws electronically, each 
                    law so voted being regarded as provisional and bound to be 
                    superseded by ongoing developments in our collective apprenticeship. 
                  However, 
                    as we all know, bombarded as we are with media information, 
                    our civilisation is teetering on the brink: war, misery, ecological 
                    disasters. If we were to take certain paths now we might irretrievably 
                    compromise our freedom, and even our survival. The very fact 
                    that we are now in a position to destroy everything should 
                    make us aware of our responsibilities and our freedom. However, 
                    if we do not succeed in convincing ourselves that we are free, 
                    collectively free, collectively intelligent, that we are linked 
                    by language in the one network of thought and decision making, 
                    if we do not manage to convince ourselves that we can consciously 
                    increase our collective freedom and intelligence, then we 
                    are in danger of being condemned to wander indefinitely
 
                    or of becoming suddenly and ignominiously extinct.  
                  I 
                    am now going to risk formulating a proposal. We must move 
                    in the direction of a more powerful and deliberately assumed 
                    freedom and collective intelligence. This is a paradoxical 
                    aim since it evaporates once it reaches the horizon of the 
                    opening-up of meaning: a collective apprenticeship which has 
                    attained the meta level, and which is becoming ever more meta. 
                    Prolonging the process of biological evolution, cultural evolution 
                    continues the opening-up of the scope of meaning.  
                  I 
                    would therefore claim that we are approaching the dawn of 
                    a new civilisation whose explicit aim will be to perfect collective 
                    human intelligence, that is to say, to indefinitely pursue 
                    the process of emancipation into whose path language has thrown 
                    us. If I have worked so hard at understanding the significance 
                    of Cyberspace, it is because it seems to me to be the most 
                    up-to-date tool available for improving our collective intelligence, 
                    the most recent path discovered for opening up our possibilities 
                    of collective choice.  
                  There 
                    are three different dimensions along which our collective 
                    intelligence can grow. There is the dimension of power-sharing 
                    along the lines of Cyber-democracy. There is the dimension 
                    of productivity and prosperity along the lines of Information 
                    Capitalism. Then there is the dimension of spiritual and artistic 
                    grace in which the multiplicity of virtual worlds and games 
                    contributes to the comprehension of the sacred world.  
                  The 
                    foundation of all other forms of collective intelligence, 
                    their base, and the structure which is the slowest to change 
                    and the hardest to move is that which relates to power. The 
                    intermediary layer, that of wealth, is more mobile, adventurous 
                    and speculative. Finally, there is the experience of life 
                    become the free-play of symbols, a game which has no other 
                    aim than the exercise of a freedom amazed by its own infinite 
                    nature. This state of grace is that of happiness as well as 
                    that of art and spirituality. The high tension and lightness 
                    associated with this state of grace carry in their wake the 
                    whirling dance of wealth and the heavy tread of power. Art 
                    is turned towards exploration, it conjures up the future and 
                    comes close to the exaltation of mysticism and prophecy.  
                  
                  Towards 
                    a Cyber-democracy 
                  
                  However, 
                    let us begin by examining the heaviest, the most opaque, the 
                    most difficult. Let us begin by looking at the structures 
                    of power. The first form which Cyber-democracy takes is the 
                    digital town, a localised virtual community which renders 
                    the social links between those who occupy the same territory 
                    more dynamic. It optimises the possibilities of exchange between 
                    resources available and projects requiring them, leaves the 
                    decision-making process more transparent and allows for a 
                    local democracy in which everyone can participate. Indeed, 
                    much more so than the nation, it is the town or metropolitan 
                    area which constitutes our true living capsule and place of 
                    real interaction, the town is one of the building blocks of 
                    our planet-wide collective intelligence.  
                  Cyber-democracy 
                    equally requires that public administration, whether it be 
                    at a local, regional, national or international level, follow 
                    the example of e-commerce enterprises. That is to say, it 
                    must become more transparent, be accessible night and day 
                    and consider us as citizens to be served rather than as subjects 
                    to be administered. Around the world, e-government seems to 
                    be moving in just such a direction. 
                  The 
                    new possibilities of on-line expression, dialogue and coordination 
                    which political and social movements benefit from, as well 
                    as the blossoming of virtual commercial agorae, can now ingeniously 
                    organise the distribution of political information and debates 
                    regarding the different possibilities of action in a manner 
                    which creates a new public sphere, one which is much more 
                    rich, open and transparent than the press or television. Finally, 
                    on-line voting, which has already been envisaged in many countries, 
                    will allow members of the public to express themselves on 
                    a wide range of topics more directly and more frequently than 
                    is currently possible. 
                  But 
                    the great mutation  and the great hope  to be 
                    brought about by Cyber-democracy resides in the possibility 
                    of one planet-wide legal, judicial and governmental system. 
                    As a network of interactive communication which will soon 
                    cover most of humanity, Cyberspace makes democracy at the 
                    level of the human race possible for the first time  
                    one no longer limited to traditional historical frontiers. 
                    Not only is one planet-wide Cyber-democracy now possible, 
                    but it is becoming more and more necessary. Ecological 
                    problems, science, technology, trade, communication are all 
                    world-wide phenomena, but legal and judicial systems would 
                    remain fragmented? Everything can be made compete: medicine, 
                    education systems, religions, cultures, ideas, merchandise 
                    and businesses. Only justice is not subject to competition, 
                    because its very nature is to mediate between competing parties. 
                    When different judicial systems are in conflict it is justice 
                    itself which is annulled. And yet, today, everything is uniting 
                     everything except national judicial systems which remain 
                    divergent and dispersed. The current planet-wide economic, 
                    technological and ecological processes can only be balanced 
                    by a legal and judicial system which is itself planet-wide. 
                  But 
                    the need for legal and judicial systems to be large enough 
                    to correctly serve humanity has a deeper, more fundamental 
                    aim than simple governance: this aim is peace. So far, cultural 
                    evolution has succeeded in outlawing slavery, proclaiming 
                    the rights of man, ensuring the notion of universal suffrage 
                    and has begun to ensure the equality of the sexes. But we 
                    have not yet attained all our goals. To our shame, we are 
                    still subject to war, to the fact that we incite to hatred, 
                    sell weapons to each other and, ultimately, kill each other. 
                  Should 
                    we so wish  and assuming that we have the courage which 
                    our freedom demands  we can now relegate war to a period 
                    in our pre-history. Rather than making a list of all the obstacles 
                    which stand between us and this goal, we should instead consider 
                    the concepts and reasons which prevent us from imagining a 
                    peaceful future to be mere illusions. Wars are always fought 
                    for futile reasons, for signs and for ideas, whereas ideas 
                    should be seen as an inexhaustible source of play. 
                  It 
                    is only one world-wide government which, by implementing laws 
                    democratically passed by the collective intelligence, has 
                    the possibility of establishing universal peace. Henceforth, 
                    war is a form of cultural backwardness. In a civilisation 
                    founded on collective intelligence, human aggression could 
                    be sublimated into economic competition, guerrilla warfare 
                    fought with information or virtual conflicts; but a world-wide 
                    judicial system would definitively outlaw murder. Once 
                    peace has been established by a world-wide government then, 
                    perhaps, it will become possible to resolve the pressing problem 
                    of our material and spiritual misery. Peace and freedom 
                    are the sine qua non of prosperity: they are the conditions, 
                    not of the end of history, but of the beginning of our real 
                    history, that which will see the continuous development of 
                    our collective intelligence and the construction of a city 
                    open to all life forms.  
                  The 
                    new law will be supple and complex, but one. It will emerge 
                    from the resolution of problems in many different virtual 
                    communities. In Cyber-democracy, the law will aim to protect 
                    the act of creation, and will attempt to provide economic, 
                    technological and artistic processes with as much support 
                    as possible. The law of collective intelligence releases creative 
                    forces. 
                  
                  Theory 
                    of Information Capitalism 
                  
                  Once 
                    peace and one world-wide, democratic law have been established, 
                    then creative efforts will no longer be threatened and prosperity 
                    will take off. Information Capitalism is the machine needed 
                    to enrich Cyber-culture. As its name indicates, its principal 
                    goods  be they its raw material or its finished products 
                     are information and ideas. This economic regime will 
                    of course still produce material goods  though these 
                    goods will become more and more intelligent, just 
                    as their conception, manufacture and sale will grow into increasingly 
                    more complex cognitive and informational procedures. There 
                    are at least three ways in which Information Capitalism is 
                    similar to communism. 
                  Firstly, 
                    information and ideas cannot be held to be the exclusive property 
                    of anybody in particular. A person who sells information does 
                    not lose the use of it once it has been sold; unlike, for 
                    example, an item of clothing or an apple. Moreover, information 
                    is now ubiquitous in Cyberspace and multiplies almost without 
                    cost. Information is free. 
                  Secondly, 
                    the ultimate source of wealth has now become clear: the intelligence 
                    and collective creativity of groups of humans. While collective 
                    intelligences force depends to an extent on technical 
                    parameters, and notably on the development of virtual worlds 
                    favouring cooperation, it also depends on the education, skill, 
                    honesty and courage of individuals who establish means of 
                    exchange and partnership. It becomes profitable to invest 
                    in knowledge and honour when prosperity depends on the quality 
                    of conversation. Collective intelligence will be all the more 
                    productive for coordinating the efforts of free individuals. 
                  Thirdly, 
                    there is the convergence of two separate trends: the remarkable 
                    growth in share ownership and in the on-line playing of the 
                    stock markets on the one hand, and the continuing mergers 
                    of multinational companies on the other hand. Soon, only three 
                    or four giant companies will be in competition in any given 
                    sector of the worldwide economy. These companies will become 
                    a sort of planet-wide public service, while ordinary citizens 
                    and producers will be able to sit in judgement on them simply 
                    by exercising their free choice of consumption and investment. 
                    Information Capitalism will move towards the common ownership 
                    of the means of production: the network, information, company 
                    shares. In the transparency of the Internet, the great conversation 
                    of the worldwide market will catch up with the free speech 
                    of democratic agorae. 
                  Cultural 
                    evolution creates new modes of social organisation, new techniques, 
                    new aesthetic forms which oblige us to exercise our freedom 
                    more and more. In this sense, the Internet and capitalism 
                    are intimately linked. By the Internet, I mean 
                    continuous invention in the freedom of communication, and 
                    by capitalism I mean the uninterrupted invention 
                    of new economic forms. Because capitalism is not a system 
                    (it is only a system for those who think in terms of systems). 
                    Capitalisms  especially Information Capitalisms 
                     unique characteristic is the ongoing search for new 
                    organisational forms, ever more supple and intelligent. Its 
                    companies constitute delicate patterns of networked virtual 
                    communities, all of which simplify their hierarchies. 
                    It invents new means of exchange which are more complex and 
                    deterritorialised and new markets which are more virtual, 
                    transparent and rapid. It produces goods which cannot be appropriated: 
                    free information, free knowledge, freeware. It calls for producers 
                    which are free and independent, yet associated in one collective 
                    intelligence. 
                  The 
                    scientific community was the first community to explicitly 
                    organise itself according to the rules of collective intelligence. 
                    Each member of this community must be aware of the findings 
                    produced by others, produce original findings him or herself 
                    and help others to do the same. As it happens, it is precisely 
                    the Internet which the scientific community chose as the means 
                    of communication capable of allowing it attain its goals. 
                    In adopting the Internet, Information Capitalism is, at least 
                    in part, adopting the methods of collective intelligence employed 
                    by the scientific community. All it needed do was replace 
                    knowledge with merchandise and then turn knowledge into the 
                    primary merchandise, that which produces all others. The medium 
                    is the message. In Information Capitalism, the largest companies 
                    become types of on-line universities or research laboratories 
                    quoted on the stock exchange; they produce knowledge, develop 
                    skills and organise cooperative undertakings.  
                  In 
                    this new competitive game, the most competitive are also the 
                    most cooperative, the most convincing are also the most transparent. 
                    Information Capitalism will carry most of humanity along with 
                    it in a never-ending dance of apprenticeship. This is a meta-game 
                    in which the best players succeed in bending the rules, succeed 
                    in initiating some kind of revolution in merchandise, in sales, 
                    in finance, in law, in the structure of the company or of 
                    the market in general
 As it moves towards a communism 
                    of intelligence, Information Capitalism is starting a permanent 
                    revolution. 
                  Those 
                    who would denounce this shout out: Look at these predators
 
                    and they are right. All infamies must be uncovered. But Information 
                    Capitalism succeeds in channelling aggression and greed into 
                    a symbolic and legal game. Evil is sublimated into the generation 
                    of wealth. On the battlefields, fire and steel shed blood 
                    in the name of symbols and ideas. In the new marketplaces, 
                    we do battle with ideas and images with the aim of exchanging 
                    signs, magical objects, communication and knowledge. Having 
                    turned to information, capitalism has abandoned the industry 
                    of carnage in favour of that of the image. 
                  General 
                    prosperity will be brought about by the free association of 
                    those who produce ideas, i.e. collective intelligence. Since 
                    true wealth is not material, goods, money, the market and 
                    the techniques of Information Capitalism will all become virtual. 
                    As it becomes more and more symbolic, the play of Information 
                    Capitalism comes to resemble art and grace. 
                  
                  The 
                    ascension towards grace 
                  
                  Art 
                    precedes the market, it invents it. Companies are now imitating 
                    art more and more: a style, a brand name, a designer label, 
                    a certain manner, know-how, sensibility or taste. Information 
                    Capitalism needs creators. Companies are in the 
                    process of becoming their advertisements, logos or cultures. 
                    If art speaks to us about the manner in which we produce meaning, 
                    and therefore speaks to us of how we speak, then Information 
                    Capitalism is selling us new means of speaking, new communicating 
                    objects and networks. In discovering new manners of producing 
                    meaning, art also discovers the next object to be sold on 
                    the market.  
                  However, 
                    despite these similarities, and despite the fact that it is 
                    itself an object to be sold, art exceeds all finality and 
                    all notions of economic value, and this because it carries 
                    us into the domain of gratuity. This artistic-religious grace 
                    is not concerned with wealth or power, but with the production 
                    of meaning, the autonomy of the production of 
                    meaning, the exploration of freedom. As we all live 
                    in language (including all cultural signs and not simply linguistic 
                    signs in the narrow sense) this production of meaning 
                    can only be collective. The artistic-religious collective 
                    intelligence does not simply investigate new forms of semiosis, 
                    but also new means of sharing meaning, that is to say, 
                    it implicates us one with the other, turns us into autonomous 
                    and unique sources of meaning. This dimension of grace, the 
                    mutual implication of independent sources of meaning, 
                    also called love, is not necessarily limited to the human 
                    race, but is rather infinitely open. 
                  Just 
                    as with spiritual quests, artistic work is judged by its ability 
                    to displace meaning. The artist prays or meditates in the 
                    sphere of signs. If information is that which can change the 
                    meaning of a situation, and if really important information 
                    can change our way of seeing, then art is a religion of information. 
                  All 
                    the great mutations in the history of language have also provoked 
                     or rather are mutations in the nature 
                    of the divine. The ideographic writing systems allowed for 
                    the development of the first complex polytheistic religions 
                     complete with their own clergy and theology. The alphabet 
                    carries monotheism: the two inventions are contemporary and 
                    all the important monotheistic religions (or universalist 
                    ones, such as Buddhism) are transmitted in alphabetical texts. 
                    The invention of the printing press was a factor in the development 
                    of the Reformation and in the creation of lay religions such 
                    as liberalism and socialism. This suggests to me that the 
                    coming of Cyberspace, which is a further step in the evolution 
                    of the power of language, is also a religious revolution 
                     digital art forms bear witness to this as, indeed, 
                    do more traditional means of expression. 
                  Although 
                    henceforth indefinitely reproducible, or rather capable of 
                    being rendered actual by virtual matrixes, and having therefore 
                    transcended the problematic of the original and the copy, 
                    works of art remain something other than a simple reproduction. 
                    They reflect that inimitable voice heard by those whose ears 
                    are turned towards the source. Because it is not concerned 
                    with the effect it may have, nor with any future success, 
                    great art, which is instead turned upstream of perception, 
                    forges the future. As Nietzsche said: great events are 
                    carried on the wings of doves. Hovering at the edge 
                    of the perceptible, the work picks up imperceptible signs, 
                    subtle signals. Artists are looking for that which eternally 
                    has not yet been named. The work, which explodes into our 
                    shared space of meaning, demands that we ask it the following 
                    question: what do you mean? What unheard of forms of meaning 
                    are you suggesting? What messages are you carrying from creative 
                    force? 
                  The 
                    arts of today  cinema, video, interactive games, virtual 
                    worlds, digital music, genetic art  are made with computers. 
                    They are all connected by the network in one critical dialogue. 
                    Art is now transmitted by digital means, that is to say, precisely 
                    by that which demonstrates the present increase in the power 
                    of language. Just as it is for the mystic, reality is also 
                    a tremendous flow of signs for the artist. The artist must 
                    turn towards the inner screen of his consciousness in order 
                    to see forms take shape. As it happens, forms take shape in 
                    digital matrixes, in networks, in interactive devices and 
                    in the cooperative procedures of virtual worlds. A work of 
                    art can never be finished, it is rather constantly growing 
                    and open to cooperation; it envelops us just as the network 
                     our new collective nervous system  does.  
                  Art 
                    also bears witness to the mutations taking place in our bodies. 
                    These are now carried by safer and faster vehicles, adulated 
                    in stadiums, gazed at on porn sites, sculpted by exercise 
                    and health foods, remodelled by medicine, drugged by the pharmaceuticals 
                    industry, extended by various prostheses, becoming part of 
                    other bodies thanks to organ banks and blood transfusion, 
                    exposed to planet-wide epidemics, inherently part of the biosphere 
                    which they eat and breathe, genetically modified, cloned, 
                    conceived in vitro. And yet, still mortal, still craving 
                    love, the body does not disappear in Cyber-culture: it is 
                    instead transformed into a hyper-body, just as our minds all 
                    join together in the networks hyper-cortex. 
                  When 
                    I surf the Net, I am exploring the intelligible world, the 
                    world of signs and of language, the virtual universe. But 
                    the Net is a world which is open, alive, sensitive, evolving, 
                    a world which invents its own laws; along with millions of 
                    others, I transform and enrich it with my acts. Freedom of 
                    expression and communication are constantly growing, overcoming 
                    numerous obstacles in the process. Cultural evolution frees 
                    up the forces of creation, allowing for the production of 
                    new sign systems and new languages which are alive and autonomous; 
                    from Information Capitalisms systems of transaction 
                    to on-line games, from virtual worlds to biotechnology, from 
                    digital art forms to robots with artificial intelligence. 
                    These new languages will become ever more interconnected and 
                    will evolve and multiply in ever more varied, complex and 
                    surprising ways; they will thus present to those gathered 
                    the surrealist mirror-image of the collective intelligence. 
                    Henceforth, culture is the life of those signs which have 
                    become independent biospheres spinning in Cyberspace.  
                  
                  The 
                    direction of the evolution 
                  
                  Man 
                    constitutes a bridge between Heaven and Earth, he forms a 
                    passageway between the natural and the supernatural. Through 
                    him, the life of signs is elevated from the life of the body 
                    where it was born and attains its autonomy through art, religion, 
                    technology, writing, science and through the world of ideas 
                    which is today growing ever more complex and functioning like 
                    a second biosphere in Cyberspace. Human language is a virtual 
                    flower which blossoms infinitely as it grows towards the invisible 
                    centre of Gaia. 
                  Cyberspace 
                    is a poetic figure which has suddenly appeared at the horizon 
                    of human experience. The constant and surprising nature of 
                    its acceleration reveals, in the present, the infinite openness 
                    which is the essence of man. The process of cultural and technological 
                    evolution is creating closer connections between us which 
                    actually open up our mental space. Cyberspace has become the 
                    placeless place where humanitys unceasing dialogue with 
                    itself can grow and expand. Writing, the alphabet, the printing 
                    press, the audiovisual media and now Cyberspace have all increased 
                    languages power. It is only now that we are beginning 
                    to understand the essence which drives us as humans, and this 
                    because evolution is bringing us back in time towards a principle 
                    which we can see more clearly every day. Language is a machine 
                    which weaves together the sources of meaning that are 
                    our minds. It is a machine which accelerates the passage 
                    of time and which allows us to learn more quickly from 
                    ourselves and from the world. It is a machine which produces 
                    collective intelligence and one which is now beginning 
                    to take control of its own evolution as well as that of the 
                    life which it supports. By looking to the future of Cyberspace, 
                    we are actually travelling back into ourselves, to the period 
                    before time where language has its origins. 
                  Life 
                    became language around the birth of man and language becomes 
                    life when turned towards its eternal future. Despite what 
                    the idolaters and materialists think, infinity is not revealed 
                    to humanity in one message, but rather through 
                    language itself, through its unlimited ability to generate 
                    meaning, that is to say by the sudden emergence of freedom 
                    in the history of the world. Each of us relives the history 
                    of our species in our own lives: that of being the point through 
                    which freedom emerges from the base matter where it has been 
                    growing since the beginning of time in order to turn back 
                    on itself and recognise itself for what it is. In the blueprint 
                    of creation  or in the adventure of evolution  
                    this is what our species must do: in that ambiguous zone where 
                    lines are transformed into dotted lines before disappearing 
                    into nothingness, we must draw the line an artist would. Language 
                    travels through us and outwards, taking shape in millions 
                    of language and culture machines; this allows us to create 
                    a new form of artificial life, one which has no name or ego 
                    and which is calling to the future, stretching out towards 
                    an untamed form of freedom. 
                  The 
                    organic life of micro-organisms and plants slowly emerged 
                    from inert matter thanks to the digital codes of DNA. The 
                    nervous systems digital code then evolved from this 
                    plant life to produce the colourful and varied world of the 
                    animal kingdom. The digital code of human language has since 
                    opened up the infinite possibilities related to art and religion: 
                    questions, narratives, signs, knowledge. Language allowed 
                    the new life of signs, culture and technology to grow within 
                    the old one. Language is alive. It is striving towards a form 
                    which will be lighter, faster, more changeable than organic 
                    life. With writing, language acquired an independent memory. 
                    It has since become universally effective, digitalised as 
                    it has been by the alphabet. With the printing press, writing 
                    invented a system for reproducing itself. As language passes 
                    through the different phases of its evolution, human culture 
                    also becomes more powerful, creative, rapid. Following the 
                    progress made by the media, culture has become more diverse 
                    and rich: it now counts new artistic, religious and technological 
                    forms as well as industrial and political revolutions. Cyberspace 
                    represents the most recent development in the evolution of 
                    language. The different elements of our culture  texts, 
                    music, images, virtual worlds, simulations, software, money 
                     are now reaching the ultimate phase of digitalisation. 
                    They have now become ubiquitous in the network  once 
                    they are somewhere, they are everywhere  and are connected 
                    by one burgeoning, multicoloured, fractal and inflationist 
                    fabric, a fabric which is in one respect the meta-text which 
                    surrounds human culture. Software is a living form of writing 
                    and has given signs a certain independence, an ability to 
                    act by themselves in the digital matrix which is their home. 
                    Cyberspace is in the process of becoming the ecosystem for 
                    the world of ideas, it is a bustling noösphere which 
                    is transforming rapidly and which is beginning to take control 
                    of the biosphere, directing its evolution towards its own 
                    ends. Life in its entirety is rising up towards the virtual, 
                    towards infinity, through the door opened by human language. 
                   ^  |